Make it simple. John Robinson is the king of making simple fills sound huge. Jeff could with ease take chances by adding a 6lick and not blink and it sounded like it was meant to be there.
I watched at NAMM Peter Erskine lay it down and funky, with such simple fills and it was great.
As to Jeff and syncopated licks, I'm sure it was worked out a few times before tracking.
For me in the studio, every time I walk into the studio it's different. I just did tracks for a guy whom was horrible and I will never let this see the light of day....We had a very hard time trying to write charts to his stuff let alone play, he could not play to a click so he went and laid his guitar part and vocal all at once, we were then given the stuff to learn, bars of 2 1/2....what si that?
A bar of 5 then a bar of like almost 3 but not quite plus the tempo was all over the map. Made for a real challenge, some tunes were easier then others.
Many times I am given a file with maybe some suggestions on a seperate track and I will just ease into it, maybe do a few passes and turn it in. Many guys are doing it this way now, I heard from Denny Fongheiser that he has not set foot in an actual recording studio in about a year, he has been doing his tracks from home.
Mna this is long...........I don't really get "into" a song, I listen for the sections and any distinctive hits that maybe a piano or guitar are playing, maybe try to play with them or even around them but staying in the contect of the tune, again thinking JR.
The more you listen to musical people like Jeff, Erskine, Carlos, Gadd..........in a pop context or even a jazz context for they are very similar, you are playing for the music. At some point it just becomes natural to WANT to play like that and not to overplay. I guess in some ways it's about growing up musically and maturing.
Mickey Curry is so about playing for the tune and just laying it down.
2 great records to play to and just absorb what it's all about are "Start The Car" by Jude Cole, and Peter Frampton self titled "black cover". JR, Jeff, Denny